A RENEWED bid has been made to prevent
members of bankrupt businessman Sean Quinn's family litigating claims that the
former Anglo Irish Bank unlawfully
"shovelled" €2.34bn loans into Quinn companies.
The special liquidators of Irish Bank Resolution
Corporation (IBRC), formerly Anglo, want the Supreme Court to overturn a High
Court decision permitting Patricia Quinnand her five children to litigate claims
Anglo advanced the loans for the unlawful purpose of propping up its share
price.
They claim Anglo illegally made loans from
September 2007 to fund margin calls on contract for difference (CFDs) positions
- which requires a seller to pay to a buyer the difference between the current
value of an asset and its value at contract time.
The CFDs were built up by Sean Quinn senior in Anglo from 2005 through
a Madeira-registered company, Bazzely, owned by the Quinn children.
The High Court also ruled the Quinns may litigate
additional claims the loans breached the Market Abuse Regulations.
IBRC had argued the Quinns should not be allowed
make those claims in their action denying liability for the €2.34bn
loans. But Mr Justice Peter Charleton, in February 2012, said it would be
contrary to public policy to shut out the Quinns from responding to the
"flagrant illegality" alleged against Anglo and Sean Quinn.
He ruled the family are entitled to advance claims
they can avoid liability for loans if they prove those loans were made for
"wholesale" market manipulation in breach of Irish and European law.
He added there may be a portion of "legitimate
debt" involved, a reference to the bank's claim that €500m loans are
unrelated to the allegedly unlawful loans. That could result in a proper
apportionment of legitimate and illegitimate debt at the end of this case if
the Quinns proved their claims, he noted.
1 comment:
This gets more farcical by the day. IBRC gave an undertaking prior to Judge Charleton's ruling that they wold except his decision whatever it was. Now they have no hesitation spending more of OUR money trying to deny the Quinn family natural justice. Justice delayed is justice denied.
Post a Comment